Film Draft Posters and Feedback

Here are the posters I have drafted for my short film:

Here is the feedback I received from my class mates on the posters:

The majority of the feedback says I need to clean up the images and use up the composition, whilst making the narrative of the short film clearer. However, from my research into short film posters, I know that they can be quite abstract and do not have to reveal to the audience what the film is about. I plan to make a google form where my target audience can vote on which most they think is the most successful.